Comb-and-MirrorDespite its roots in European paganism, Halloween is a thoroughly American holiday. During the Gilded Age, Americans took Halloween quite seriously, even going so far as to celebrate it wherever they happened to be–as German society soon discovered when the expatriates residing in Berlin shook up the Kaiser’s capital with “games, Jack-o-lanterns, mince pies, and other Hallowe’en hijinks.” Americans of this time spread their Hallowe’en celebrations from the 31st of October until the morning of the 3rd of November, a period know as Allhallowtide.

Bobbing for ApplesDuring the Colonial era, only those who kept the customs of England celebrated Hallowe’en, partaking of such amusements as apple-ducking and snapping, and girls trying the apple-paring charm to reveal their lovers’ initials and the comb-and-mirror test to see their faces. Otherwise, ballads were sung and stories told–for the dead were thought to return on Hallowe’en. However, the customs did not take root in American culture until the late 1840s, when the widespread migration of the Irish to the United States, and the immigration of the Scottish after the 1870s, solidified the popularity of the holiday. Hallowe’en was initially a home celebration, where Irish- and Scottish-Americans hosted parties and balls, with perhaps a recitation of Robert Burns’ poem “Halloween” or a telling of Irish legends.

By the turn-of-the century the holiday was thoroughly commercialized. Halloween postcards, and decorations were soldby Dennison Manufacturing Company (which published its first Halloween catalog in 1909) and the Beistle Company. It could also be thoroughly unsafe. Now vandalism and violence in the streets terrorized the holiday, and by the 1910s neighborhood organizations came together to encourage a safe Halloween. Rather than playing tricks on their neighbors, children went from door to door receiving treats. By the 1930s, “beggar’s nights” had become very popular, and the concept of “trick-or-treating” rose in popularity and became the practice for Halloween celebrations after WWII.

Halloween Party

As for traditional celebrations: bobbing for apples, carved pumpkins, and candy corn (The Wunderle Candy Company of Philadelphia was the first to commercially produce candy corn in the 1880s) commemorated the harvest season. While it was not unusual for the children to be put to bed and the adults to depart for riotous Hallowe’en parties, the holiday became one of the few occasions where people of all ages could celebrate with one another.

Further Reading:
The book of Hallowe’en by Ruth Edna Kelley
Games for Hallow-e’en by Mary E. Blain
Food Timeline: Halloween foods: Traditions and Party Menus
Wikipedia: Halloween customs
Halloween: An American Holiday, An American History by Lesley Bannatyne
Death Makes A Holiday: A Cultural History of Halloween by David J. Skal

Related Posts with Thumbnails


9 Comments on Hallowe’en In the Gilded Age

  1. Barbara
    October 28, 2009 at 8:28 AM (10 years ago)

    Wonderful post!! I really enjoyed reading about past Halloween traditions.

  2. ani d'onofrio
    October 28, 2009 at 8:50 AM (10 years ago)

    Thank you for writing an enjoyable article on Halloween. Part of it reminded me of an article I read a few years back regarding the celebration of Halloween in France by Americans. When interviewed, one Parisian sniffed, “It is a bizarre holiday!!!” He felt it was one of the worst things Americans brought to France. Oh well. I intend to send a link to this to a few friends who will appreciate your history.

  3. Victoria Janssen
    October 28, 2009 at 10:40 AM (10 years ago)

    A most excellent post!

  4. Elizabeth Kerri Mahon
    October 28, 2009 at 1:03 PM (10 years ago)

    Thanks so much for post Evangeline. I have a Halloween scene in my WIP, and I’m glad to see that I’ve gotten most of the details right! It’s hard to believe they had candy corn in the 1880’s, although I’ve had some that tasted as if it was that old.

  5. heidenkind
    October 29, 2009 at 5:52 PM (10 years ago)

    How fun! I never thought about Hallowe’en as so much of an American holiday. Actually, I hate Hallowe’en, but that’s a whole different issue. 😛

4Pingbacks & Trackbacks on Hallowe’en In the Gilded Age

  1. […] October 24, 2016October 24, 2016 / Bronwyn Mroz Benson Halloween is next week and I’m still trying to think of something appropriately Halloween-y to talk about without just doing witches or something like that.  We’ll see what I come up with… In the mean time, here’s some things I’ve found interesting recently, including information about Halloween in the Gilded Age.  Another link discusses Augustus Saint-Gaudens, who I recently read some about in David McCullough’s The Greater Journey: Americans in Paris, which I’d really recommend. “Long-Toppled Statue of King George III to Ride Again, From a Brooklyn Studio” A story of a POW and some kindness from WWI “How the Poppy Came to Symbolize World War I” Some information on American sculpture at the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair With Halloween coming up, some fun about Halloween in the Gilded Age […]