Fascinating Women: May Yohé

May Yohe

Perhaps it was the possession of the ill-fated and cursed Hope Diamond which destined Mary Augusta Yohé to a life of infamy and ruin. Nonetheless, you must say that her fate was that of a series of missteps and foolish actions–rather in the vein of Lily Bart–with which the ebullient American musical actress chose to guide her life.

Mary Augusta, known henceforth as “May,” was born in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania on April 6, 1866 to William W. Yohé, a former officer of a Pennsylvania Regiment during the Civil War, and Lizzie Batcheller, the daughter of a hotel proprietor. The two separated sometime during May’s childhood, and Lizzie supported the two with a successful business (of which has yet to be revealed) in Philadelphia. May’s father, William, was known for his dark good looks and musical talents, and Lizzie spent her free time singing in church choirs. Lizzie had apparently acquired enough money and success to send twelve year old May abroad for her education, and three years later she returned home, pretty, polished, and poised. However, May wanted to go on stage. She went in as chorus girl, and within a few years she emerged as a star after a well received turn as “Prince Prettywitz” in the Crystal Slipper at the Chicago Opera House in the summer of 1887. From then on, May’s career was a dazzling success, a success which baffled her critics, who found her “an indifferent actress [who] does not possess good stage presence, and has a figure by no means striking.” But perhaps that was what audiences desired: a beautiful woman who was on stage to have fun.

By the early 1890s, May was famous for another reason: her rumored elopement with Lord Francis Hope, the younger brother and heir presumptive to the Duke of Newcastle-under-Lyne, who was owner of a half-dissipated estate. Lord Francis himself, who acquired the surname “Hope” and the legendary Hope Diamond from a grandmother’s bequest, was in dire financial straits, and after his quiet 1894 marriage to May, he and she continued their extravagant ways. Not even a year later, the two had frittered away his entire inheritance–the land, the estates, the pictures, the heirlooms, and the Hope Diamond. But as a future Duke and Duchess, Lord and Lady Francis Hope could beg or borrow on their expectations, which they did, further increasing their exorbitant debts.

In 1900, flush with ill-gotten wealth, Francis and May undertook a world tour. On their way home, they acquired an acquaintance, the dashing Captain Putnam Bradlee Strong, who was one of the most popular officers in the US Army and a particular favorite of President McKinley. May took one look at Captain Strong and fell head over heels in love. Rather than continue on to England with Lord Francis and, in the manner of the well-born Englishwoman of the day, keep Captain Strong as a lover, May deserted her husband for her darling Bradlee (American women were much too sentimental and conventional to English eyes). May became Mrs Strong in San Francisco, but within two years, their quarrels and relative poverty tore apart the marriage, and she charged that Captain Strong made off with £20,000 worth of jewelry. Strong appeared in London soon after to denounce this claim, and May followed him, where a reconciliation was had.

May and Bradlee, both penniless but flush with publicity, decamped for America where May returned to the stage in an act created for the two. Unfortunately, May’s theatrical success had been forgotten and Captain Strong had no acting talents whatsoever. Rather than remain shackled to a waning star, the captain filed for bankruptcy and divorce in 1905. After this, May sunk into obscurity, and years of poverty followed, whereupon she took positions as a scrubwoman, a housekeeper, and a janitor. In 1914, she wed Captain John A. Smuts, and remained married to him for quite some time. When in early 1938, LIFE Magazine featured her in a short article, it was only because of her tenuous connection with the Hope Diamond, which by then was in the possession of Washington D.C. socialite Evalyn Walsh McLean, and the novelty of a former owner working for the WPA as a statistics research clerk for $16.50 a week. A few months after this feature, the tempestuous May died at age 72 of “arterial sclerotic heart disease and chronic vascular nephritis.”


More from Evangeline Holland
11 replies on “Fascinating Women: May Yohé”
    1. @ Elizabeth: She certainly should have! But “l’amour, l’amour,” as the Countess in The Women would proclaim.

      @Lauren: Thank you! I wanted to feature an American “heiress” and May was an anomaly in the canon.

      @heidenkind: Me too! Especially considering that $16.50 in 2010 dollars is $200!

  1. says: eva

    A few corrections- Lizzie was a seamstress and William’s parents, Caleb and Mary Yohe, owned the Eagle Hotel in Bethlehem, PA
    Capt Strong and May ran away to Japan via San Francisco but were not married yet, Hope and May finalized their divorce while she was in Asia with Strong.
    After their return to the states, Strong ran off with her jewels and fled to Europe after putting them up in a pawnshop and then giving his mother the pawn ticket. May recovered her jewels and followed Strong to Europe meeting up with him in Lisbon, from there they actually eloped and were married in Buenos Ares. Strong was the one who fled for Asia and May applied for divorce in Oregon on basis of abandonment…
    id tell you more but you’ll just have to wait until the book comes out 🙂

  2. says: eva

    im a research assistant at the smithsonian, my boss is writing her biography right now, and hopefully it will get published soon! You can learn so much about her just by looking at the old newspapers, because she was always trying to get her name in the papers

  3. says: NJB

    It is quite likely that May also had a child in Oregon that she gave up for adoption (who the father was will remain a mystery) The child is listed on a census from 1910 decades before there was any thought of inheritance (from the wealthy Strong family)

    Where did you find information on May’s parents being divorced? I’ve never read that before although they are listed as divorced in the 1880 census. May told reporters that her father died, which he did, but not before the divorce. She is a hard one to research – she would fib if she felt the need (her birth year is all over the place)
    I think it was from her preference for younger men!
    Great work on Mary Augusta Yohe – you did your homework!

    ps – she has a facebook page!

    1. I’m loving all of this new information about May Yohe! I actually found a good dose of my information from genealogy forums, and the rest from the archives of The New York Times. Thanks for stopping by and filling in even more holes in her biography!

  4. says: Kimberly

    Thank you all for the information you posted about May. I’ve had an interest in her life for many years as she was related to my beloved grandma who led quite a colorful life herself. Seems “wild women” run in my family. I’ve acquired a few pieces of memorabilia from May’s career that I treasure and keep on display over my piano. I’m just learning how to do genealogical research and am looking forward to finding out just how we’re related and more about her life.

Comments are closed.